Why Independent Pharmacies Matter to Healthcare Access in Birmingham
When a neighborhood pharmacy closes, the loss is bigger than an empty storefront. Patients lose a familiar place to fill prescriptions, ask questions, receive vaccines, arrange delivery, and solve problems before they become emergencies.
For someone with reliable transportation and flexible work hours, adding another stop across town may feel inconvenient. For an older adult, a caregiver, a person with limited mobility, or someone working two jobs, that extra distance can become a real barrier to care.
Independent pharmacies are not simply smaller versions of national chains. They are part of the local healthcare infrastructure, and their ability to remain open affects whether patients can get help close to home.
Pharmacy access is a public health issue
A 2025 study published in JAMA Network Open examined pharmacy access across the contiguous United States. Researchers estimated that 57.1 million people, or 17.7 percent of the population studied, lived in pharmacy deserts. Another 28.9 million people, or 8.9 percent, lived in communities that depended on a single “keystone pharmacy” for access.
Independent and franchise pharmacies represented about 39.8 percent of the pharmacies in the study but 44.9 percent of the keystone pharmacies. In other words, independent pharmacies were disproportionately represented among the locations whose closure could leave a community without reasonable pharmacy access.
This is not only a rural issue. The study found that millions of people living in pharmacy deserts or relying on one pharmacy were in urban areas. Transportation, work schedules, disability, neighborhood design, and pharmacy network restrictions can create access problems even when a map shows another location several miles away.
A community pharmacy does more than fill bottles

The prescription counter is only one part of modern pharmacy care. A local pharmacy may provide:
Vaccinations
Medication counseling
Compliance blister packaging
Prescription and over-the-counter delivery
Refill coordination
Support for caregivers and long-term care communities
Help understanding insurance claims and medication options
Point-of-care or limited testing services when available
Birmingham Apothecary provides vaccinations, compliance packaging, delivery, medication and supplement consultations, long-term care support, and other patient services from its Five Points South location. That combination matters because health needs rarely arrive one at a time.
A patient may come in for a refill and remember a vaccine question. A caregiver may pick up a prescription and realize that blister packaging could simplify a complicated schedule. Someone without transportation may learn that delivery is available. Those connections happen because the pharmacy is accessible and the team has time to listen.
Patient choice is being shaped behind the scenes
Many patients assume their insurance company and pharmacy are the only parties involved in a prescription. Pharmacy benefit managers, or PBMs, also influence formularies, pharmacy networks, reimbursement, and where certain prescriptions can be filled.
The Federal Trade Commission’s July 2024 interim staff report found that the six largest PBMs managed nearly 95 percent of prescriptions filled in the United States. The top three processed nearly 80 percent of approximately 6.6 billion prescriptions dispensed in 2023.
The FTC reported that the largest PBMs are vertically integrated with major insurers and affiliated pharmacies. Staff raised concerns that this structure may create incentives to steer patients toward affiliated pharmacies while placing smaller, unaffiliated pharmacies at a disadvantage.
In a second interim report released in January 2025, FTC staff found that the three largest PBMs reimbursed their affiliated pharmacies at higher rates than unaffiliated pharmacies on nearly every specialty generic drug examined. The report also estimated that the three PBMs generated $1.4 billion from spread pricing on the specialty generic drugs analyzed from 2017 through 2022.
These are national findings, but the consequences are local. When reimbursement does not cover what a pharmacy paid for a medication, or when a network blocks a patient from using the pharmacy they prefer, the neighborhood feels the impact.
What disappears when an independent pharmacy closes
The most obvious loss is convenience, but several less visible losses follow:
Continuity. A team that knows a patient’s history may notice when something looks different, such as a duplicate therapy, a refill arriving too early, or confusion after a hospital discharge.
Flexibility. Independent teams can often spend time troubleshooting claims, contacting a prescriber, explaining alternatives, or coordinating with a caregiver.
Local services. Delivery routes, employer vaccine clinics, long-term care support, and neighborhood-specific programs may disappear with the pharmacy.
Competition. Fewer pharmacies mean fewer places for patients to compare service, access, and available pricing options.
Community knowledge. A local pharmacy understands the transportation barriers, organizations, employers, and health concerns in the area it serves.
None of this means every independent pharmacy can solve every insurance or medication problem. It means patients benefit when they have a real choice and more than one pathway to care.
How patients can support pharmacy access
Supporting independent pharmacies is not limited to buying retail items. Practical actions include:
Use a local pharmacy for prescriptions when your plan allows it.
Transfer and consolidate prescriptions so one team can review the full medication picture.
Ask about vaccinations, blister packaging, delivery, and consultation services.
Tell your employer or benefits administrator when a plan prevents you from using the pharmacy you prefer.
Learn how pharmacy networks and benefit design can affect where you can fill prescriptions, and ask questions when access feels limited.
Share accurate information about local pharmacy services with caregivers, neighbors, and community groups.
Supporting local pharmacy access can start with a practical question: “Can I use the pharmacy that knows my medications and serves my community?”
More than a century of local care
Birmingham Apothecary is the oldest pharmacy in Birmingham and has served the community for more than 100 years. The pharmacy has changed with the city, but its mission remains focused on accessible, high-quality care and personalized attention.
Keeping that kind of care available requires more than nostalgia. It requires patients, employers, health plans, and policymakers to recognize that access has value.
When you choose an independent pharmacy, ask questions about your benefits, or speak up for fair access, you are helping protect a piece of Birmingham’s healthcare infrastructure.
Visit Birmingham Apothecary at 1032 20th Street South in Five Points South or call 205-251-4248 to learn about prescriptions, vaccinations, compliance packaging, delivery, and other patient services.




Comments